Boiler Room Fraud, Recognising and Avoiding Investment Fraud
Investment fraud refers to cases where false financial services are offered with the intent of deceiving investors and exploiting them financially.
Investment Fraud, At a glance
- Investment fraud is a form of financial fraud in which criminals promise high returns from supposedly safe capital market investments. Their real aim is to steal your money.
- Fraudsters build trust, appear friendly, and seem to advise professionally. They then put pressure on you to make quick investments.
- Unrealistic returns, opaque websites, and "cold calls" are warning signs. Recognising these early can prevent significant financial losses.
Definition, What is Investment Fraud or Boiler Room Fraud?
Investment fraud, also known as boiler room fraud/scam, investment scam, and cybertrading fraud, is a particularly devious form of financial fraud. Criminals use social engineering techniques to convince victims to willingly transfer money, believing they are investing safely and profitably.
Fraudsters entice victims with flashy advertisements and seemingly attractive offers for stocks, funds, cryptocurrencies, and term deposit accounts. Once individuals show interest, systematic manipulation begins — often extended over a period — which ultimately leads investors to place their capital in worthless or fictitious investment products.
Common Cases, Types of Investment Fraud?
Term Deposit Fraud
Fraudsters advertise lucrative term deposits via internet ads or paid search engine results. Interest rates appear attractive but not overly suspicious. Bonus programmes, such as discounted deposits for significant capital like €100,000, are commonly offered.
Victims must open accounts, usually at foreign banks, under seemingly straightforward procedures. These accounts, however, are not genuinely opened for victims but belong to others.
Further information on these schemes is available on the BaFin website under "Unsound Term Deposit Offers".
Cyber trading
Victims start with smaller investments (approx. €250) and later larger sums, lured by promised value increases, e.g., in cryptocurrencies, binary options, or stocks. Clicking on advertisements leads victims to deceptively realistic websites, featuring endorsements from celebrities or TV formats that were never truly involved.
To learn more, victims are required to provide personal details like name, phone number, and email address. This is followed by emails and contact from an alleged broker. Investment progress is displayed via professionally designed internet platforms with charts and trading tools mimicking genuine trading websites. Simulated data adapts based on the user’s financial behaviour.
Investment scam
In an investment scam, supposedly professional agencies tempt victims with IPO subscriptions for stocks or future projects. The offerings often seem meticulously prepared and highly professional.
In reality, these may consist of overpriced shares, or fictitious securities that directly redirect victims’ money to fraudsters’ accounts.
Typical Procedure, How Does Investment Fraud Work?
Phase 1, Luring
On the internet, social media platforms, and in specialised magazines, fraudsters promote so-called "insider tips" or innovative investment products claiming to offer incredibly high returns with minimal risk.
Common methods to approach (potential) investors include:
- Unexpected phone calls from unknown individuals offering enticing opportunities
- Online search results, e.g., on cryptocurrencies, leading to fraudulent websites
- Advertisements in respected online magazines or journals promoting supposedly lucrative investments
- Promotions on social media platforms, e.g., featuring alleged "secret deals" endorsed by popular TV programme that promise high profits
Victims often engage by clicking on links, responding to emails, or through direct communication from fraudsters.
Phase 2, First Contact
In the next step, victims are usually contacted by a broker through phone calls, often using foreign numbers (e.g., prefixes from the UK, Austria, or Switzerland) or fake () numbers.
Even if victims initially express scepticism towards the call or offer, fraudsters counter with strategic arguments and convincing explanations to win trust.
The conversation typically starts with discussions about small investment amounts, such as €250 or €500. Investment options include , , , or cryptocurrency investments.
After transferring the initial sum, victims receive online access to their accounts or wallets on the fraudulent platform. Here, they can supposedly view their investments, which show increasing returns. These manipulations aim to build trust, as the website data is entirely falsified.
Phase 3, Building Trust
During this phase, fraudsters focus on earning victims' trust by portraying themselves as friendly, knowledgeable advisors with personalised service. Victims are continuously in contact with so-called brokers who appear professional and competent.
Investment fraud uses social engineering methods, including:
- Mirroring the victim’s interests
- Reinforcing dissatisfaction with traditional banks
- Complimenting the victim’s financial knowledge
- Raising targeted expectations
- Extracting detailed information about the victim’s financial status and company situation
Phase 4, Intensive Manipulation
Once trust has been established, friendly advice turns into pressure or emotional manipulation. Victims are urged to invest larger sums — sometimes even encouraged to take out loans.
High-pressure tactics are often utilised, such as time-sensitive offers with statements like "This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity" or "If you don't act now, you'll lose the chance for profits."
To avoid intervention from others, victims are manipulated into isolation, being persuaded not to discuss details with their bank or any third party.
This stage is especially critical in investment fraud cases, as many victims opt to invest significant sums — against all reservations or advice from their bank or colleagues.
Fraudulent investments usually flow to:
- Third-party payment services set up specifically for this purpose
- Fake cryptocurrency exchanges where wallets are controlled by fraudsters
- Domestic and international bank accounts that falsely appear to be registered in the victim’s name
Phase 5, Breaking Contact
Fraud becomes apparent when victims demand the withdrawal of promised profits or their invested capital.
Initially, small sums might be returned without issue, as this builds victim trust. Some victims even conduct test withdrawals to ensure the legitimacy of the platform. Fraudsters exploit this behaviour.
However, when victims request significant amounts or their full capital, the excuses begin:
- Claims of contract terms that were never disclosed before.
- Immediate withdrawals supposedly involve steep fees or deductions.
- Fraudsters demand a “proof of liquidity”.
- Larger amounts can supposedly only be withdrawn using credit cards.
- High withholding taxes must allegedly be paid upfront.
When victims refuse to pay further amounts due to suspicion or financial constraints, the fraudsters abruptly disappear. Phone numbers become unavailable, email addresses deactivated, communication channels removed, and the website vanishes.
Warning: Many investment fraud schemes also operate as pyramid schemes, where new victim deposits are used to pay out supposed profits to earlier investors. This approach only works as long as continuous inflow of funds from new victims is maintained.
Warning Signs, How to Identify Investment Fraud
Unrealistic promises
Returns far exceed market standards and seem overly good to be true.
Suspicious web addresses
Links in internet advertisements don’t match the source listed in the message.
Psychological pressure
Fraudsters aggressively push victims to invest quickly, particularly in cryptocurrencies.
Loans as a trap
Dodgy brokers suggest borrowing money when victims face liquidity issues so they can keep investing.
Remote device access
Victims are urged under false pretences to install remote desktop software, giving fraudsters control over their computer or smartphone.
Non-transparent investment offers
No clear or credible information is provided about the investment plans or financial products advertised.
Falsified tax and liquidity confirmations
With professionally forged documents, victims are asked to pay further amounts as “precondition” for withdrawals.
Foreign accounts
Recipients of payments often do not match the advertised trading platform name. Alternatively, victims are falsely named as the account holders but remain listed solely as payment purposes.
Further details on recognising fraudulent providers or unauthorised transactions can be found on the BaFin website. In addition, Stiftung Warentest provides a warning list (only in German) to help identify unscrupulous firms and financial products.
Prevention, Tips: Protecting Yourself from Investment Fraud
Be cautious with unrealistic profit promises
If you are promised high returns with no risk or rapid doubling of your capital, proceed with caution. Legitimate investments typically do not yield extreme returns within a short period – nor do they come with guarantees.
Only share personal information with care
Provide personal details such as your phone number, email, or copies of identification documents only to trustworthy entities. Fraudsters exploit this information for targeted social engineering or even to open accounts in your name.
Resist being placed under pressure
Fraudsters often use urgency or emotional tactics like "only valid today," "last chance," or "don’t miss out on something big." Keep calm. Never let yourself be pushed into making hasty decisions.
Maintain a critical viewpoint
Fraudsters are well-prepared for any objections or questions you may have and will present seemingly logical replies to put you at ease.
Verify links, websites, and legal information
Fake platforms are often designed to look convincingly genuine. Inspect the website URL carefully and check whether the legal details (e.g., company name, address, and contact information) are complete and plausible. Any omission or questionable information is a red flag.
Be wary of unexpected calls
Trust our highest security standards supposedly unique investment opportunity, exercise extreme caution. For these unsolicited calls – known as "cold calls" – hang up immediately and block the number.
Reaction in Case of Fraud, What to Do If You've Been Targeted by Investment Fraud
Bank Transfer:
If you’ve transferred funds to a fraudulent trading platform, contact your bank immediately to request a reversal of the transaction, provided this is still possible.
Contact your corporate client adviser or call our corporate clients hotline at +49 69 1368 0527 (English) or +49 69 1362 6360 (German) - Monday – Friday, 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM.
Credit Card Payment:
Contact your credit card issuer or financial institution to initiate a "chargeback" – a process to cancel or reverse your credit card transaction.
Seek Legal Advice:
A lawyer specialising in investment fraud can help you recover your money. Always verify the lawyer’s credibility, as there are fraudulent lawyers exploiting victims’ distress. You can check their legitimacy in the official nationwide lawyer directory.
File a Report with Police or BaFin:
If you’ve fallen victim to investment fraud, report the case to the police, either at your local station or online via the digital police portal. You can also register the fraud with BaFin, Germany's Federal Financial Supervisory Authority.
Schufa Check:
If you’ve shared identification documents, you may be at risk of identity theft (only in German). Use Schufa (credit agency) to monitor whether accounts or loans have been fraudulently opened in your name.
Take Warnings Seriously:
If your bank issues a warning concerning fraud, don’t disregard it. Act promptly, and review the advice carefully.
Security at Commerzbank, Trust Our Highest Security Standards
High-security standards
The corporate client portal and its various applications are regularly tested and reviewed by security teams during development.
Deactivating fraudulent phishing websites
Although we cannot prevent phishing emails from arriving in your inbox, we ensure that the fraudulent websites linked within such emails are deactivated promptly in most cases.
Two-factor authentication
Access to our online portal is secured by a two-factor authentication mechanism (2FA), an extra security measure. Although 2FA cannot completely prevent phishing, it significantly enhances the protection of your account.
Personal advice
If you have any questions or security concerns, please contact your dedicated corporate client adviser directly.
You might also be interested in
Benefit from attractive partner offers from our cooperation partners. Simply inform yourself and choose.
Cybersecurity is an issue that affects all corporates, but many do not yet pay enough attention to it.
Through cunning tricks and deception, criminals use social engineering to gain access to your sensitive data. Here’s how you can protect yourself from this scam.